Major Structural Changes in UK Freight

Major Structural Changes in UK Freight

The Department for Transport has recently published its annual Road Freight Transport Statistics Bulletin 2009, and interpreting the figures provides a fascinating analysis of the changes occurring in the Distribution Sector. This year’s publication is significant in that not only does it show the impact of recession when compared with 2008, but also as the 20^th edition, showing the fundamental changes over two decades.

Unsurprisingly, total tonnage uplifted declined markedly in 2009 compared to the previous year, but the balance of goods moved between different sectors has continued recent trends.  The volume of food and drink products has been at a stable 370 million tonnes for three years, after a fairly constant upward trend, whereas all other categories declined, noticeably Bulk Products, which fell from 620 million tonnes to 440 million tonnes year on year. Perhaps worryingly for British Manufacturing, this compares with levels of over 600 million tonnes being uplifted in this sector even during the recession years of the early nineteen nineties.

Analysis of usage by vehicle type shows artics moving 58% of goods compared to just 40% in 1989.  Not only does this show the impact of increased vehicle weights on improving efficiencies, but also goes some way to explain why unit haulage rates have failed to keep pace with inflation, whilst still allowing haulage businesses to continue.

However, from a cost analysts’ perspective, the most interesting statistic must be the change in the proportion of goods being moved by own-account vehicles versus 3^rd party hire and reward hauliers. In 1989, hire and reward operators uplifted 60% of goods (by weight), declining slightly to 57% in 1991 as the recession bit. However, with a trend for more companies outsourcing logistics functions, this then peaked to 67% in 2001. A gradual decline to 61% in 2007 has then been followed by big drops to 51% in 2009. Actual volumes for the hire and reward centre have dropped from a peak of 1,145m tonnes in 2007 to just 723m tonnes in 2009 – a 47% drop ! Undoubtedly, the impact has been large numbers of providers disappearing from the scene with record administrations and insolvencies in the sector, and the survivors following rigorous cost cutting programmes and capacity reductions. For the future, however, from the service procurors perspective, this means reduced competition as hopefully volumes begin to recover.

Although the own account sector suffered a small volume reduction to 699 million tonnes, this was still the third highest volume moved in this sector since 1989. However, the sector moved its goods further than any previous year and therefore recorded its highest ever tonne kilometre measure. The re-emergence of the own account sector must be a relief to suppliers of fleet services: our internal data shows that margins charged on fleet supplies (eg fuel, tyres, maintenance, fleet insurance, etc.) are consistently higher than being achieved by the same suppliers to the hire and reward sector.

Therefore, despite the fact that own account operators are working their fleets harder, there are still major opportunities to improve their cost base through detailed effective procurement reviews.

See all Logistics Team Blogs